Current:Home > MarketsPower Plants on Indian Reservations Get No Break on Emissions Rules -Prime Capital Blueprint
Power Plants on Indian Reservations Get No Break on Emissions Rules
View
Date:2025-04-14 22:24:29
Four Western power plants that emit more carbon dioxide than the 20 fossil-fuel-fired plants in Massachusetts thought they would be getting a break under the Obama administration’s new carbon regulations––until the final rule ended up treating them just like all the other plants in the country.
The plants are located on Native American reservations, and under an earlier proposal, they were required to reduce emissions by less than 5 percent. But the final version of the rule, released earlier this month, has set a reduction target of about 20 percent.
A majority of the reductions are to come from two mammoth coal plants on the Navajo reservation in Arizona and New Mexico—the Navajo Generating Station and the Four Corners Power Plant. They provide power to half a million homes and have been pinpointed by the Environmental Protection Agency as a major source of pollution––and a cause for reduced visibility in the Grand Canyon.
These two plants alone emit more than 28 million tons of carbon dioxide each year, triple the emissions from facilities in Washington state, fueling a vicious cycle of drought and worsening climate change. The two other power plants are on the Fort Mojave Reservation in Arizona and the Uintah and Ouray Indian Reservation in Utah.
Environmental groups have charged that the Navajo plants are responsible for premature deaths, hundreds of asthma attacks and hundreds of millions of dollars of annual health costs. The plants, which are owned by public utilities and the federal government, export a majority of the power out of the reservation to serve homes and businesses as far away as Las Vegas and help deliver Arizona’s share of the Colorado River water to Tucson and Phoenix. Meanwhile, a third of Navajo Nation residents remain without electricity in their homes.
Tribal leaders contend that power plants on Indian land deserve special consideration.
“The Navajo Nation is a uniquely disadvantaged people and their unique situation justified some accommodation,” Ben Shelly, president of the Navajo Nation, wrote in a letter to the EPA. He contends that the region’s underdeveloped economy, high unemployment rates and reliance on coal are the result of policies enacted by the federal government over several decades. If the coal plants decrease power production to meet emissions targets, Navajos will lose jobs and its government will receive less revenue, he said.
Many local groups, however, disagree.
“I don’t think we need special treatment,” said Colleen Cooley of the grassroots nonprofit Diné CARE. “We should be held to the same standards as the rest of the country.” (Diné means “the people” in Navajo, and CARE is an abbreviation for Citizens Against Ruining our Environment.)
Cooley’s Diné CARE and other grassroots groups say the Navajo leaders are not serving the best interest of the community. The Navajo lands have been mined for coal and uranium for decades, Cooley said, resulting in contamination of water sources and air pollution. She said it’s time to shift to new, less damaging power sources such as wind and solar.
The Obama administration’s carbon regulations for power plants aim to reduce emissions nationwide 32 percent by 2030 from 2005 levels. In its final version of the rule, the EPA set uniform standards for all fossil-fueled power plants in the country. A coal plant on tribal land is now expected to achieve the same emissions reductions as a coal plant in Kentucky or New York, a move that the EPA sees as more equitable. The result is that coal plants on tribal lands—and in coal heavy states such as Kentucky and West Virginia—are facing much more stringent targets than they expected.
The EPA has taken special efforts to ensure that the power plant rules don’t disproportionately affect minorities, including indigenous people. Because dirty power plants often exist in low-income communities, the EPA has laid out tools to assess how changes to the operation of the plants will affect emission levels in neighborhoods nearby. The EPA will also be assessing compliance plans to ensure the regulations do not increase air pollution in those communities.
The tribes do not have an ownership stake in any of the facilities, but they are allowed to coordinate a plan to reduce emissions while minimizing the impact on their economies. Tribes that want to submit a compliance plan must first apply for treatment as a state. If the EPA doesn’t approve, or the tribes decide not to submit a plan, the EPA will impose one.
veryGood! (747)
Related
- Nevada attorney general revives 2020 fake electors case
- 'Pops love you': Young father of 2 killed during fist fight at Louisiana bar
- South Carolina has $1.8 billion but doesn’t know where the money came from or where it should go
- When is Tax Day 2024? Deadlines for filing tax returns, extensions and what you need to know
- Will the 'Yellowstone' finale be the last episode? What we know about Season 6, spinoffs
- Smuggling suspect knew of frigid cold before Indian family’s death on Canada border, prosecutors say
- 'No ordinary bridge': What made the Francis Scott Key Bridge a historic wonder
- Indictment accuses Rwandan man of lying about role in his country’s 1994 genocide to come to US
- All That You Wanted to Know About She’s All That
- How Jesse McCartney Managed to Avoid the Stereotypical Child Star Downfall
Ranking
- New Zealand official reverses visa refusal for US conservative influencer Candace Owens
- Is the April 2024 eclipse safe for pets? Why experts want you to leave them at home.
- Sean “Diddy” Combs Breaks Silence After Federal Agents Raid His Homes
- Christine Quinn's Husband Christian Dumontet Denies Assault While Detailing Fight That Led to 911 Call
- Meet the volunteers risking their lives to deliver Christmas gifts to children in Haiti
- U.N. Security Council passes resolution demanding immediate Hamas-Israel war cease-fire, release of hostages
- Hop on Over to Old Navy, Where You Can Score 50% off During Their Easter Sale, With Deals Starting at $10
- Here’s what we know about the allegations against Shohei Ohtani’s interpreter, Ippei Mizuhara
Recommendation
Juan Soto to be introduced by Mets at Citi Field after striking record $765 million, 15
After a county restricted transgender women in sports, a roller derby league said, ‘No way’
Katie Maloney Accused of Having Sex With This Vanderpump Rules Alum
Travelers through Maine’s biggest airport can now fly to the moon. Or, at least, a chunk of it
Kylie Jenner Shows Off Sweet Notes From Nieces Dream Kardashian & Chicago West
Krispy Kreme doughnuts coming to McDonald's locations nationwide by the end of 2026
Trader Joe's bananas: Chain is raising price of fruit for first time in 20 years
NBC has cut ties with former RNC head Ronna McDaniel after employee objections, some on the air